Learn more

Lipstick on a pig

When a brand refresh puts off the real problem

A fresh coat of paint feels like progress. New logo, updated colours, cleaner typography. The website looks sharper. The business cards arrive. Everyone feels optimistic.

Then the same problems resurface. Leads still don't convert. The pitch still falls flat. Customers still don't get what makes you different. The refresh didn't fix anything because the problem was never the logo.

This is the lipstick-on-a-pig trap. A cosmetic refresh applied to a brand with fundamental positioning, offer, or delivery issues. It creates the illusion of change while postponing the difficult decisions that actually need to be made.

The real consequence is that it consumes the budget and time you need to fix what's actually broken. You defer the hard work, reset the clock, and end up back where you started with a nicer logo on a brand that still doesn't connect.

When a refresh makes sense

A visual refresh can be exactly the right move for a sound business with dated or inconsistent branding. If your positioning is clear, your offer is relevant, your difference is credible, and you deliver on the promise, then yes, bring the identity up to date. Express what's already working in a way that reflects where you are now.

But if enquiries are thin or conversion is weak, the cause could be design, visibility, usability, market fit, delivery, or positioning. New visuals might help. They might not. You need to investigate before you commission.

Cosmetic vs strategic

A cosmetic refresh updates the surface. A strategic rebrand starts with diagnosing what's not working, fixing the underlying issue, then expressing that change through identity, messaging, and experience.

If your brand isn't connecting, look beyond its appearance. Be clear about what it stands for, who it's for, why it matters, and whether you can deliver consistently.

Strategic work is harder. It requires honest assessment of your offer, your market position, your points of difference, and your ability to execute. It might mean changing what you sell, how you sell it, or who you sell it to. The rebrand becomes the expression of that change, not a substitute for it.

A rebrand tied to genuine strategic change can absolutely solve problems. A cosmetic-only refresh applied to a failing brand just postpones them.

Without clarifying what the brand stands for and how it competes, you're building on sand. The visual identity, the messaging, the marketing tools all flow from that foundation.

Strategy came first for Andersens

Andersens engaged us to build a local area marketing portal, but a few things were in the way of doing it well. Our research showed the sector was becoming more commoditised, which made it harder to stand apart from competitors. A shiny new brand portal and some more retail-led, discount-driven advertising was only ever going to add to the problem. And so we recognised the need to go back to the foundation.

The strategic solution was to introduce the ‘Right at Home’  proposition and begin to tell the story of how Andersens' service is superior to the competition.

Andersens Right at Home campaign: a woman opening curtains in her home.
Andersens’ “Right at Home” proposition, expressed through lifestyle-led creative by Creature.

‍

A short set of checks before you commission a refresh

  • Can you explain your positioning in a way that's clear, relevant, and distinct?
  • Can you define who you're for and what problem you solve for them?
  • Do you have a credible difference that matters to that audience?
  • Do you deliver on your brand promise consistently?

If any of those are unclear or unsupported, then a Strategic refresh is probably in order. Fix the foundations first. Then express the change through a refreshed brand identity that actually means something.

A strong corporate identity is valuable

It builds recognition, communicates professionalism, and expresses your position in the market. But it can't create a position that doesn't exist. It can't fix a weak offer by itself. It can't substitute for a clear point of view or a credible reason to choose you.

If the fundamentals are sound, a refresh can be exactly what you need. If they're not, a rebrand might still be part of the solution, but only after you've done the harder work of diagnosing and fixing what's broken.

The good news is that once you've sorted the strategy, the creative work becomes easier and more effective. You're expressing something real, not dressing up a problem.

If you're not sure whether you need a refresh or something deeper, talk to Creature.

Written by